ARC review, book review, fantasy

ARC review: Dark Hilarity by Joseph Sale

Wolfkin, lizardmen and gorilli- oh my! Sale’s latest novel is a feast for fantasy lovers.

Bonded by their love of the music of Valentine Killshot, preteens Tara and Erica’s friendship is stretched to breaking point by a horrific shared event.

Seven years later, the women confront their past, and each other, in the dreaming world of Dark Hilarity.

Probably Sale’s most instantly accessible novel, this portal fantasy takes place in both Bournemouth and the world of Dae’Estha, which dwells under the Dark Stars.

The Laughing God and the Dark Stars are the closest links to Sale’s previous work, along with excellent world building, strong characterization and a solid story. However, there is much new here, such as the female protagonists, the animal creatures that dwell in Dae’Estha which seem equally an ode to Lewis and to Dungeons and Dragons, and the prose that contains a flavor of China Melville in the description of the dreaming world.

The themes of drug addiction, familial abuse and post traumatic stress disorder are realistically portrayed.

Every word counts in this novel.

It’s hard to know whether the relationship between Tara and Nicola is intended as a friendship or romance, and perhaps it is deliberately left vague to avoid the white knight trope which it comes close to resembling.

I would have liked Tara to have had more agency in the final act, as the ending felt a little flat and rushed to me, lacking the catharsis I had hoped for the characters.

A lot is left unresolved at the end as well, which came across more as keeping good stuff for future novels rather than leaving things purposefully vague.

All in all a great read with compelling characters and an imaginative world.

I award Dark Hilarity

Dark Hilarity is available for preorder $2.60 ebook on Amazon and will be released on January 31st 2021.

I received a free copy from the author in exchange for an honest review.

Click on the names below to read my reviews of some of Joseph Sale’s other books.

The Meaning of the Dark

The Darkest Touch


God’s of the Black Gate

Beyond the Black Gate

Return to the Black Gate

Save Game

6 thoughts on “ARC review: Dark Hilarity by Joseph Sale”

  1. Great review Iseult – lots of really good points. I found the novel myself ingenious and surprising – for example, that Nicola, not Tara, is the real heroine which took me a while to work out. The 12 AA rules are very cleverly deployed. Finally, I think, it is the layering of the details, the firm command of plot, the fascinating characters and worlds that he creates, that make this distinctive. Best wishes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, James. I agree. I love how the 12 steps is woven into the narrative. However, I spotted Nicola from the start. Her upbringing, her triumph against adversity, her heart – it showed her as the heroine from the first time we see her helping Tara.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s